(note: I will throughout this piece avoid using any names. This is mostly because I do not wish to spend massive amounts of time and space with Twitter screenshots, and so forth. There should be enough for a serious reader to do hashtag and youtube research without my having to make this writ longer than it already is. Please view the evidence and drama for yourself and make up your own mind about what is going on. My only plea, is that you look at both sides before choosing a side.)
In the American (well, United States) Culture War, the latest battlegrounds are the realms of classic geekdom, namely comics and tabletop gaming.
Now, as a Dane, I don’t really get a lot of news from the front via traditional news outlets (in Denmark, and Europe in general, being a geek is still just a fairly harmless subculture which most normies don’t care about), so my news come from U.S. websites and social media. I even joined Twitter (as it is slowly dying anyway) just to keep up on the drama there.
So, in case you have no idea about what’s going on on the Western Front. I’ll do a quick recap. And please, remember that this is MY take on what is happening rather than some objective truth (which would be WAY too hard to get at by now).
#Comicsgate
If I were tasked to keep politics out of this I could only describe Comicsgate as: Follwing a massive ammount of drama on Twitter, over politics, a prominent artist and writer left DC Comics (creators of Superman and Batman for any normies reading this) and decided to make his own comic book named Cyberfrog. A massive ammount of drama followed including personal attacks and all the shit you expect from people venting their dirty laundry in social media. A number of creators who either alligned with the ex-DC artist or dislike the people he had a problem with have been using crowdfunding to fund their comics, while being accused by their detractors of manipulating their fans, as well as being White nationalist, racist mysogynist, and so forth and so on.
As I said that is just the tip, and the reality of why #comicsgate became a thing goes much deeper.
Now what I stated above is probably (the true cause is fairly hard to nail down hard) what began the movement known as #comicsgate, but there are some things which happened alongside these events which need to be taken into account.
If you’ve been following comics for the past few years, and not just watching the movies, you know that there have been some major changes to some of the classic characters, most notably at Marvel Comics. Long stories short: Thor has been replaced by a woman (and no, Thor hasn’t changed sex as is often the case with gods from ancient pantheons, and neither is Thor a title, the new female Thor is also named Thor – which makes no sense at all to anyone from Scandinavia), Wolverine is dead and has been replaced by X-23 (essentially a young female version of him, but with less drinking and smoking), the Iron Man suit has once again been taken over by someone other than Tony Stark (a young Black female named Riri Williams, and even The Punisher for a short spin), Hulk is now Asian (and not angry or angsty), Iceman from the X-Men is now gay, Captain America was really a Nazi sleeper agent, and Spider-Man is now a Black Latino called Miles Morales.
At the same time, new superheroes were introduced such as Squirrelgirl, a lesbian Captain Marvel, and a muslim Capt Marvel. The stories were written by new writers, and many comic books nerds didn’t like the heroes, for various reasons. Now, to be fair, for some it was that they didn’t like the new take on gender, sexuality, depiction of the female figure (“de-sexualized” rather than the classic “kalos kagathos”-like aesthetics which had previously been the norm), and the increase of ethnic minorities as superheroes. Now, I’m not going to defend somebody objecting to a new superhero based solely on the colour of their skin, their religious (or lack thereof) observance, their sexual preference, their gender identity, or the contents of their pants. But neither am I going to buy the agument that any dislike to the characters mentioned above which cited other reasons were really “dogwhistlling”. I tend to take the written word fairly literally, especially if there are no internal markers in that statement. Now, if somebody signals otherwise elsewhere, then of course that should be taken into account, but the blanket statement often used by those opposed to the critique, that any who dislike the reimaginged comic books were racist, misongynist, homo-, and transphobic, and so on and so forth.
As a person who stopped reading the periodical comic books in the early 2000’s, partly because Spider-Man changed in ways I, and most other danish fans didn’t like. And, partly because the only store which carried these books closed in my vicinity. I have to say that any of these changes (and they are changes, otherwise they would have different names and try to stand on their own feet) would be enough for me toquit the books once again. The only exception being the Riri Williams Iron Man, until I read a few of them.
Now here is where it gets interesting…
Because of the changes sales started dropping and fans (the angry ones) wrote the creators on Twitter and other social media. The managing of the fandom went sour here, with high profile people insulting fans and telling them that the comics they had been supporting for decades were “not for them” now. The fans reacted and the shitshow continued…
Currently the #comicsgate phenomenon, has turned into several creators going the indie route and using social media to promote their taste in comic books attempting to swing sales and showing that there is an alternative to the mainstream outlets.
It goes without saying that in the massive “long tail” of the indie market, some comic books are written by people on the political extremes, and espousing their particular extremist ideology. This is a matter of fact. Another matter of fact is that the bove does not apply to ALL indie comics creators. There is much more to the “long tail” of comics than just extremist politics.
The latest news (8/6 2018) is that the two biggest names in the #comicsgate movement have ended their crowdfunding campaigns with the artist who was at the center of the whole thing raking in an impressive $500k in funding. Another creator made the Top Ten list with his self published comic book. And certain comic book publisher have reported losses of up to 91%.
GenCon 2018
If you’re a tabletop gamer, you most likely know at least something about GenCon, but if you’re not here is a small summary: GenCon is a huge tabletop gaming convention in Indianapolis, where geeks from all over the U.S. and Canada (but also from the rest of the world) meet to play games and revel in the celebration of their fellow hobbyists.
At least it was. Because this year the Cuture War was also fought here, and in a different way than you may expect.
Now as the following is about an active criminal case, I will keep away from speculating too much, which of course means using the word alleged. I will however do, what is most polite until the matter has been resolved in a court of law, and believe the accuation of the victim, until it is disproven. As I do when, for example, a woman accuses someone of sexual harrasment.
So what happened? A controversial youtuber was physically assaulted outside of a bar by another man, following the first day at GenCon. The youtuber managed to flee into the bar after which the attacker fled the scene.
As I stated above this is an ongoing investigation. And in fact, the particulars aren’t too important for the case I’m trying to make here.
If you bring thousands of people together some crimes are bound to happen. That is the unfortunate nature of humans. Previous GenCons and other cons, recently Origins 2018, have had issues with various charges of harrasment and the odd fight between people who have some sort of falling out over something. But this is the first time the has been an allegedly premeditated, politically motivated assault at one of these events.
Now, politics have always been a part of tabletop gaming. It has just never been violent. And what happened at GenCon 2018, is a tragic first. Me writing this, is in no way an attempt to say that one man punching another is a worse offense than a man harrasing of sexually assaulting a woman, or whatever. I’m not playing comparatives here. But the fact that it is premeditated, that is motivated not by pathology or previous interaction, but by politics, is the real tragedy. As is the con’s lack of action or official repsonse (as of this writing).
Tabletop gaming was one of the last bastions of what you could call “normie geeks” although that word shouldn’t make sense. It was where we laid our political differences aside and swapped them for our character’s. It was an escape. An escape from the shrill voices of political extremists and a world we couldn’t change by our actons alone. It was a place where a suit-wearing banker could play an effeminate elf seated next to a transgendered person playing a combat-junkie dwarf, together plotting agains the punk playing a religious zealot. And everybody were having fun.
The assault at GenCon 2018, was as much an assault on the belief that in this space, who we were outside didn’t matter. It was an assault on the openess to meet new people. Because now, now there is a good reason to keep away from strangers at cons. Because they might label you a nazi/SJW and attack you, preemptively in their mind. Or they might just be there to beat up nerds, while appropriating a sub-culture they decided to include in their political ideology’s new lebensraum.
Conclusion
Two of the classical realms of geekdom, find themselves the battleground of the U.S. Culture War. Much like many European countries during, these sub-cultures were neutral ground, until the Culture War came to them. Because of this, they are easy prey. They are divided, lack any real direction, and any leadership. And they are being targeted by organised attempts at winning them to a particular side. Now why would anyone attack a sub-culture which has always been inclusive, diverse, and peaceful? You may ask. Because it is a show of strength. The Culture War has had a hard time at really winning any major battles in literature, cinematography, and so forth (they are either too big and too well founded, or too niche, and too easily ignored), so beating up on nerds, seems like an easy win. And as the fandom divides and is forced into taking sides or leave the cultural invaders to their newly appropriated sub-culture. Several questions remain, such as; what is next? And when the Culture War in the U.S. is over, what is left? A similar War in Europe?
My only advice is: Speak out! Don’t let our games and comic books regress into obscurity. We cannot allow a few political extremists to taint our hobby and the sense of community, which we have built over decades. If a company or creator begins to preach ideology which you disagree with, cut them off. If they target your friends and paint them as your enemy, even if you agree with their basic philosophy, cut off the company. Their rhetoric isn’t worth ruining real life friendships over. Vote with your wallet, and don’t try to demonize others, simply for disagreeing with you. And never, ever, accept violence against anybody, try to justify the attacker, or blame the victim. I you truly feel that people who do not believe as you, should be excluded, or bodily harmed, for this perceived “offense”, then you are truly a sad case, and a good reason why our sub-culture might die out entirely.
A final word
I have in this writ kept most of my opinions to myself. I do have them, but the truth of the matter is that I choose my hobbies over my personal politics. There are some of the people I have written about who I geniuinely dislike, and others that I like. But at the end of the day there are simply a limit to how much I feel like I can sit by and quietly watch.
Searchwords:
GenCon 2018, the quartering, attack at GenCon, Comicsgate, Diversity & Comics, Cyberfrog
Hashtags:
#Comicsgate, #movetheneedle